The old piano store site at 206 East Market Street has come before the Board of Architectural Review several times since 2025: a renovation approved in April 2025, demolition, a concept review in March 2026, and a new inn, restaurant and homes plan that the BAR deferred twice and then approved with conditions on August 3, 2026.
Earlier1996BAR case BAR 96-15: porch alterations and addition
2019Case TLHP-2019-0074: paint color change
2024Site plan waiver TLSPWV2024-0012
2025Administrative certificate for added work on the block walls
Apr 23BAR approves renovation and minor addition (TLHPBR2025-0012)
Sep 17BAR members recall approving the storefront work
Nov 3Staff confirm demolition to the ground was approved
Nov 19Staff update to the BAR on the piano store site
Feb 19Planning Commission: staff name the site as ripe for redevelopment
Mar 18BAR pre-application look at a 4-story mixed-use concept
May 20BAR hearing on new construction; deferred to July 15
Jul 15BAR second review; deferred to August 3 work session
Latest ↓Aug 3The BAR approved the certificate of appropriateness for the new mixed-use building, with conditions
Vote count from a news report; official minutes not yet posted.
Current status
Pending official minutes
BAR approved the certificate of appropriateness with conditions on August 3, 2026. Vote count from a news report; official minutes not yet posted.
What’s next: Next steps named by staff: waterline conflict and a minor special exception. The August 3 staff report says a minor special exception will be required for the updated number of dwelling units (p. 2), and that a Town waterline conflicts with the building footprint (pp. 3-4). No filing for either was found in the records reviewed.
Known gaps: Official BAR minutes for July 15 and August 3, 2026 aren't posted yet; outcomes for the 1996, 2019 and 2024 items aren't stated in the records.
History
1996 · 1 event
1996
Recorded
BAR case BAR 96-15: porch alterations and addition
Listed in the History of Cases in the 2025 staff report. The outcome is not stated in the record reviewed.
Administrative certificate for added work on the block walls
The May 2026 staff report says an administrative Certificate of Appropriateness was later approved for additional work on the concrete block walls, followed by partial demolition. The exact date is not stated.
BAR approves renovation and minor addition (TLHPBR2025-0012)
Renovation, a minor addition, and exterior changes to the circa-1961 non-contributing building. Staff recommended approval. The BAR approved it 6-0-1, with one member absent, with conditions (minutes pp. 2-3; staff report pp. 1-6).
Planning Commission: staff name the site as ripe for redevelopment
During the Zoning Ordinance rewrite, Town staff mentioned the old piano store site as one of a handful of downtown sites for new construction. Mention only, no action on the site.
BAR hearing on new construction; deferred to July 15
TLHPBR2026-0014: new construction with an inn, a restaurant, five homes, and first-floor parking. Staff recommended discussion and deferral. The public hearing was held and left open, and the BAR deferred the case to July 15, 6-0-1, with one member recused (minutes p. 3; staff report pp. 1-2).
BAR second review; deferred to August 3 work session
Second submission. The August 3 staff report (p. 2) records that the Board deferred the case to the August 3 work session. Official July 15 minutes are not yet posted.
The BAR approved the certificate of appropriateness for the new mixed-use building, with conditions
The BAR approved the certificate of appropriateness for the new mixed-use building, with conditions. Staff had recommended discussion and deferral and also offered an approval motion.
206 East Market Street (PIN 231393935000) is a non-contributing site in the H-1 Overlay District, the Old and Historic District. Case TLHPBR2026-0014 is a certificate of appropriateness for new mixed-use construction: an inn, a restaurant, five homes, and parking on the first floor. The owner is Madison Dale, LLC; the 2025 owner was JARS Market Street LLC.
Announced tally: 4-0, with one recused and two absent.
No official BAR roll-call is on the record. The 4-0 tally, with one recused and two absent, is a news tally from Loudoun Now, not an official roll call. Member-by-member marks are not stored, because the news report as used on the page does not name which members voted, recused, or were absent.
Last updated Saturday, November 14, 2026, afternoon, America/New_York.